Summer Silents – Lillian Gish and Broken Blossoms (1919)

Theatrical poster for Broken Blossoms (1919)Broken Blossoms (1919) is a significant departure for D. W. Griffith away from the prestigious epics he had produced by 1918 (The Birth of a Nation, Intolerance, Hearts of the World), toward something more straightforward yet delicately ethereal.  Lillian Gish stars as Lucy, the 15-year-old daughter of prizefighter Battling Burrows (played to the sadistic hilt by Donald Crisp).  Waifish Lucy is the object of Battling’s abuse and the outlet for his anger.  Lucy cowers when she comes near him, ever fearful that she will receive yet another beating for some unknown offense.  Incredibly, Burrows reprimands her for her constant state of fear. “Why can’t you smile?” he snarls.  Ever compliant, Lucy takes two fingers and forces the corners of her mouth up in a bizarre attempt to smile for her father.  As in the climactic closet scene, Lucy is the picture of tragedy here, when we see that something so common as a smile is completely foreign to her abusive life.

Intertitle card for Broken Blossoms (1919)One day while in town shopping for the evening meal, we see that a Chinese shopkeeper, Cheng Huan (Richard Barthelmess) lets his gaze linger adoringly on little Lucy.  There is no violent sexuality or malice in his look, as might be expected from her abusive father, but rather a sort of dreamy quality.  Lucy is his vision of heaven in the pits of the grimy Limehouse district in London.  Barthelmess as the Chinese Cheng does not stoop to easy ethnic stereotypes, which are readily available from Griffith (the film’s subtitle is “The Yellow Man and the Girl”).  Some of the film’s title cards contain an interesting mixture of Anglo paternalism (one referencing Battling’s attitudes toward Cheng describes how he hates anyone not born in his own country of England) with blatant ethnic slurs (after being rescued by Cheng, Lucy asks him, “What makes you so good to me, Chinky?”).  This is a step beyond the sort of typing exhibited in Birth, but it is nonetheless very visible.

Lillian Gish and Richard Barthelmess in Broken Blossoms (1919)Inevitably, Burrows goes on to beat Lucy into a senseless heap.  She struggles to make her way out of this den of violence, and wanders the fog-lined streets of Limehouse.  Exhausted, she collapses in the middle of Cheng’s shop.  In a slight opium stupor, Cheng cannot believe that this vision has come to his little cubbyhole.  Wasting no time, he carries the senseless Lucy upstairs and outfits the room into something fit for a princess so she can make a full recovery.

The climax of the film comes during the famous “closet scene.”  Burrows discovers that Lucy has been recovering in one of the upstairs rooms of Cheng’s shop.  Outraged that his daughter may have had relations with Cheng, he storms into the shop, racing upstairs and trashes the apartment.  He grabs Lucy and takes her back home, where he prepares to giver her the beating of a lifetime.  Totally given over to terror, Lucy locks herself in a closet, begging Burrows not to beat her because “t’ain’t nothing wrong.”  Lucy runs in circles within the narrow closet, her face a mask of total shock all the while clutching a little doll given to her by Cheng.  While preparing for this scene, Lillian visited a mental asylum in order to learn the true look of terror.  Her performance in this scene is nothing short of masterful, displaying the sort of tragedy that no child actor could ever achieve (Lillian initially balked at Griffith’s request that she play Lucy, because, at 25, she thought herself too old for the part).  Burrows takes a hatchet to the door, and finally kills Lucy with his rage.

The lifeless Lucy (Lillian Gish) in Broken Blossoms (1919)Of course, tragedy can be the only ending to the story of such brokenness.  Cheng finds the lifeless Lucy, and brings her back to his shop.  He lays her out on the bed she used, putting things around her as he would on a funeral pyre.  Cheng shoots Burrows, which is another tragedy in itself.  He originally came to England from China in order to spread the pacifist meassage of the Buddha.  With nothing else to live for, he then kills himself.

The photography in Broken Blossoms is some of the most beautiful that I have ever seen in a Griffith film.  Griffith makes liberal use of tinting in order to show daytime and nighttime, which further lends itself to the ethereal mood of the film.  Clocking in at only 90 minutes, the story of Blossoms is succinct and splendidly told.  Every scene has its place (which is more than I can say for the more operatic Birth) and every actor is allowed to explore the characters to the fullest extent of creativity.  This films is truly a masterful example of not only Griffith’s and Gish’s work, but of silent cinema as a whole.


9 Responses to “Summer Silents – Lillian Gish and Broken Blossoms (1919)”

  1. I love Lillian Gish. I wish I could be as iconic as she managed to become. Alas, I know I never will be! Congrats on joining the LAMB.

  2. leclisse Says:

    Thank you for the welcome! Yes, I think Lillian will always be considered one of the great names of cinema, but I think a lot of people remember her for her place in everything rather than for her films (besides Birth of a Nation, that is).

  3. silent films are not my forte but this web site is awesome!!!


  4. Fantastic review of this silent masterpiece, I hung with every word!

    BROKEN BLOSSOMS is perhaps D.W. Griffith’s most rewarding film to experience. It is surely my own personal favorite of all his films, and that includes the much more auspicious INTOLERANCE and BIRTH OF A NATION. Of course the reason comes down to emotional resonance. I would myself excuse that occasional mawkishness as a product of the period, and the stereotyping is likewise typical of films made in the teens and 20’s. Gish is magnificent, and the performance, attacked by some. has been validated decades later. Only in THE WIND is she as superlative, methinks.

  5. leclisse Says:

    I quite agree, Sam — BROKEN BLOSSOMS is such a magnificent and resonant showcase for Lillian’s talents. I love the fact that Griffith scaled back so much from his penchant for epics, because, above all, this story is one that requires delicacy and understatement in order to drive its tragedy home. I think the simplicity of Lucy and her relationship with Cheng only adds to the poignancy of the story. It feels completely real, not something removed and exotic like the French Revolution or the Civil War. This film has been my most rewarding experience with Griffith, and I’m glad that, as you said, it has been popularly validated.

  6. Rebecca Stewart Says:

    As a white female Sinophile, I find this film endearing and memorable. It is rare that a film depicts the white female feelings for an Asian male in romantic, sympathetic, caring style. Praise for the film, and genuine appreciation.

    R.S. (a.k.a ChinaBleu)

  7. leclisse Says:

    I can’t think of another example in film at this time that would show such a sympathetic relationship between a white woman (a young girl, no less) and a nonwhite man. I would guess that this may have stirred some ire on the part of intolerant audiences (particularly in the South), but it’s hard to say because the film is nowhere near as controversial as BIRTH OF A NATION. Griffith may have compensated for that danger by shaping Lucy and Cheng’s relationship as one based on sympathy alone — as a devoted Buddhist, Cheng appears asexual, much like a monk would, and Lucy is only trying to escape an abusive situation.

  8. I was lucky enough to see this in NYC around 1985 at the Beacon Theater as part of their “Sounds of the Silents” film festival. It was an amazing experience, especially with the live organ accompanyment. Such a great film.

  9. There is definately a lot to find out about this issue.
    I really like all of the points you’ve made.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: